FAQ
Questions & answers
Everything you need to know before your day on the water. Don't see your question? Just call or text.
Booking & trips
How do I book a trip?
Call or text Capt. Jacob at (239) 671-0244, email Jacob@sanibelislandfishingco.com, or fill out the Book Now form. Tarpon season dates fill up early, so reach out as soon as you know your travel dates.
How many people can come?
Up to 5 guests per boat. Rates cover up to 4 guests. A 5th guest is an additional $75. Every trip is private, so you'll never share the boat with strangers. Tarpon trips are limited to 3 guests. Have a group of more than 5? We offer multiple-boat trips. Call or text (239) 671-0244 to set one up.
Which trip length should I pick?
A half day (4 hours) is perfect for younger kids and first-timers. A 3/4 day (6 hours) or full day (8 hours) lets us run farther, follow the bite, and combine spots. Nearshore trips start at 6 hours because of the run into the Gulf.
Where do trips leave from?
Trips depart from Sanibel and Fort Myers. Your exact meeting spot is confirmed when you book.
On the boat
Are kids and beginners welcome?
Absolutely. Many of our trips are families with young kids or people who have never fished before. We'll handle the rigging, baiting and coaching so everyone has a good time.
What's included?
Every trip includes your fishing license (covered under the captain's state-issued license), rods, reels, bait, tackle, bottled water and ice.
What should I bring?
Sunscreen, polarized sunglasses, a hat, a light long-sleeve dry-fit shirt, snacks or lunch, and any drinks you'd like. Shoes or sandals with a good grip are best on deck.
Can we keep our fish?
Tarpon are always released. Many other species can be kept when they're in season and within Florida's size and bag limits. See the current fish size & bag limits from FWC.
What if the weather is bad?
Safety comes first. If the forecast looks unsafe, Capt. Jacob will reach out to talk about rescheduling. Check the local wind & weather for Sanibel.
Inshore fishing
What can we catch inshore around Sanibel?
Snook, redfish and spotted seatrout are the main targets year-round. Depending on the season, we also catch sheepshead, pompano, mangrove snapper and black drum, along with ladyfish, jacks and sharks.
How much does an inshore fishing charter cost?
A half-day (4-hour) inshore trip is $600, a 3/4 day (6 hours) is $900 and a full day (8 hours) is $1,200. Rates cover up to 4 guests. A 5th guest is an additional $75.
Is an inshore charter a good trip for kids?
Yes. Inshore trips stay in calm, protected waters close to the islands, so there's less time on the boat ride and less chance of seasickness. A half-day trip is a good length for younger kids.
What is the best time of year for inshore fishing?
Inshore fishing is good year-round. We catch snook, trout and redfish all year, with the snook bite best in the spring and summer and the redfish bite best in the fall and spring, while trout fishing stays good year-round. Winter brings sheepshead, the occasional black drum and migrating sandbar sharks. See our Sanibel Island Fishing Report for a month-by-month look.
Tarpon fishing
When is tarpon season around Sanibel?
Tarpon start showing up in the spring and stick around through the summer, with the best fishing usually from April into July. The fall also offers great opportunities to catch tarpon as they feed on large schools of baitfish off the beaches. Call to talk about the best dates for your trip.
How much does a tarpon fishing charter cost?
A 3/4-day (6-hour) tarpon trip is $1,000 and a full day (8 hours) is $1,300. When the tides line up, a 4-hour afternoon Hill Tide trip is $700. Tarpon trips are private and limited to 3 guests.
What is a Hill Tide trip?
Hill tides are the strong outgoing tides around the new and full moons in late spring and summer, when tarpon feed hard on crabs flushing out through the passes. It's a shorter 4-hour afternoon trip, and it's only offered when those tides line up.
Shelling tours
Where do shelling tours go?
Most tours head to the beaches of North Captiva, which you can only reach by boat or plane, and Cayo Costa, which you can only reach by boat.
How much does a private shelling tour cost?
A half-day (4-hour) private tour is $600, a 3/4 day (6 hours) is $900 and a full day (8 hours) is $1,100. That's the price for the whole boat, not per person. Rates cover up to 4 guests. A 5th guest is an additional $75.
When is the best time to go shelling on Sanibel and Captiva?
Shelling is good all the time on North Captiva and Cayo Costa, so you don't need to wait for a certain tide to go. A low tide uncovers more beach and can make it even better, especially early in the morning. Shelling is also often great after a storm or a few days of west or northwest wind, and winter cold fronts tend to push a lot of shells onto the beaches.
Can I keep the shells I find?
Empty shells are yours to keep. Collecting live shells, meaning any shell with an animal still inside, is against the law in Lee County, and the same goes for live sand dollars and starfish. We'll help you check before anything goes in the bag.
Can we fish on a shelling trip?
Yes. Combo trips are a favorite: we'll shell the islands for part of the day and fish for the rest. Rods, bait and tackle are on board, and fishing licenses are covered. Just let us know when you book.
Is this a good trip for kids?
It's one of our most family-friendly trips. It's relaxed, there's plenty to see, and kids love the shell hunting.
Dolphin & eco tours
Will we see dolphins?
Most days, yes. Bottlenose dolphins live around Sanibel, Captiva and Pine Island Sound year-round and often ride alongside the boat. They're wild animals, so we can't promise what shows up, but they're one of the most common sightings on our tours.
Is the dolphin tour private?
Yes. Every tour is private for your group of up to 5 guests, so you'll never share the boat with strangers. We can stop, slow down or change plans whenever something catches your eye.
When can we see manatees?
Manatees are most often spotted in the bays and around the mangroves during the warmer months. In the winter they tend to move to warmer water, so sightings are less common.
What else might we see?
Ospreys, brown pelicans, roseate spoonbills, herons, egrets and other wading birds are common. In the summer, loggerhead sea turtles nest on Sanibel's beaches, and you may see one surface near the boat.
Alligator hunts
Do you guide alligator hunts?
Yes. We guide alligator hunts all across Florida during the season. See the Guided Alligator Hunts page for details.
Do I need a tag?
Yes. Alligator hunting in Florida is regulated by the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC), and each hunt needs an alligator CITES harvest tag. These tags are issued through an FWC application drawing that opens each year in early May. Good news: we usually have tags available for our guided hunts, so you may not need to draw your own. Call Capt. Jacob for details.
Do I need my own State of Florida alligator harvest CITES tag?
Not necessarily. In Florida, every alligator that’s harvested must have a state-issued CITES tag. The tags come from the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC), and each harvest permit includes two of them. We usually have tags available for our guided hunts, so you can hunt with us without having your own. If you did draw your own tags, call Capt. Jacob or fill out the hunt request form, and we’ll plan your hunt around the tags you were awarded. Whether you use our tags or your own, anyone who helps capture, restrain, land or dispatch the alligator needs an Alligator Trapping Agent License, unless they have been awarded their own alligator CITES tags. For example, holding a bangstick, harpoon or other alligator harvest equipment can be considered helping with the take. The license costs $51.50 at Go Outdoors Florida. Hunters 15 and younger don’t need one. Guests who just ride along to watch don’t need an Alligator Trapping Agent License, but they can’t take part in the hunt. Call Capt. Jacob at (239) 671-0244 to check tag availability for your dates.
When is alligator season?
Florida's statewide alligator season runs August 15 through November 1. Permit applications open in early May, so call before then to plan your hunt.
How do harvest weeks work?
Alligator harvest tags are awarded through FWC's random drawing. When you draw a tag, you're assigned one harvest week during the first four weeks of the season:
- Harvest Period 1: August 15 – August 21
- Harvest Period 2: August 22 – August 28
- Harvest Period 3: August 29 – September 4
- Harvest Period 4: September 5 – September 11
If you haven't harvested during your assigned week, you can hunt any day from September 12 through November 1.
How do hunt areas work, and where do you hunt?
When you apply for alligator tags, you choose the areas you’d like to hunt. FWC divides the state into harvest units, such as a specific lake, marsh or section of river, and large lakes like Okeechobee are split into separate units. Some permits cover an entire county. If you’re drawn, your tags are only good in the area listed on your permit, during your assigned harvest week. You can look up the areas on FWC’s harvest unit maps. We hunt all over Florida, so wherever you drew, call Capt. Jacob or fill out the hunt request form and we’ll plan your hunt around it.
How much does a hunt cost?
Pricing depends mainly on whose tags you hunt with. If you drew your own alligator CITES tags, your guided hunt costs less. If you hunt on one of our tags, it costs more. Call or text (239) 671-0244 for current pricing.
Can beginners come?
Yes. Many of our hunters are first-timers. Your guide will explain everything before the hunt and stay with you every step of the way.
Still have questions?
Call or text Capt. Jacob at (239) 671-0244. He's happy to help you plan.